Main Course Recipes

Cowboy Steak

4 servings

Craving a steakhouse experience at home? This Cowboy Steak recipe delivers big, bold flavor without any fuss. Whether you're grilling or pan-searing, this method ensures a juicy and perfectly cooked steak every time. With a few basic ingredients and easy-to-follow steps, you'll be enjoying a restaurant-quality cowboy steak in the comfort of your own kitchen. Read More

★★★★★1x(read the reviews)👁486x
Published: 4.6.2026
Main Course Recipes
Gluten-freeLow-carb
15 min.
45 min.
1/5
704 calories Per Serving (of 4) Read More

Before You Start

Let’s talk about important parts of the recipe before you start…

Jump to Recipe

Welcome to My Cowboy Steak Kitchen

Hello everyone, I am Tom the Chef, and I am thrilled to guide you through my signature Cowboy Steak recipe. Whenever I want a truly spectacular meal at home, this thick, bone-in cut of beef is my absolute go-to choice. I have perfected both the grill and pan methods to give you options, ensuring you get the perfect sear every single time. The real secret to my success lies in the preparation, where I use a simple but flavorful marinade featuring oil and salt. I always let the meat rest before cooking, and I never, ever trim the fat. Taking the time to finish it in the oven makes all the difference in the world!

Read more

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Etiam ligula pede, sagittis quis,Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit. Etiam ligula pede, sagittis quis, Lorem ipsum dolor sit.

Read less
Cowboy Steak - Meat preparation

Preparing the Beef and the Marinade

When I start my Cowboy Steak, the very first thing I do is rinse the beef under cold water. I cannot stress enough that you should never trim the fat, pound the meat, or cut it into smaller pieces. That fat is absolutely essential for flavor! After rinsing, I massage the meat with my marinade, which includes a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil, four cloves of garlic, and a generous pinch of salt and pepper. I make sure every inch is covered before moving to the next crucial step.

The Importance of Letting the Meat Rest

After applying the oil and salt marinade, I cover the Cowboy Steak with plastic wrap and let it rest at room temperature. I leave it for at least 30 minutes, but no more than 1 hour. This resting period is critical because it prevents the beef from getting a rubbery texture when it finally hits the hot pan or grill. It also allows the fat to soften slightly, preparing it for the perfect sear.

Mastering the Pan Sear and Oven Finish

If I am not using my grill, I love to sear my Cowboy Steak in a pan. I start by preheating my oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Then, I heat two tablespoons of frying oil in my pan over medium-high heat, adding two fresh rosemary sprigs. I sear the beef for about one to two minutes per side. After taking the pan off the burner, I pour the leftover marinade over the steak and add eight slices of butter. It then goes into the oven to finish. I always turn the meat halfway through to ensure it cooks evenly.

Perfecting the Grill Technique

For those days when I want to cook outside, I use the grill for my Cowboy Steak. I preheat it to 350 degrees Fahrenheit and grill the beef evenly on both sides until I achieve a beautiful sear, keeping the lid closed. I watch it carefully; if the fat causes flare-ups or starts to burn, I lower the heat. As an optional modification that is not part of the original recipe, you can add soaked hickory wood chips to your coals for a smoky flavor, but remember this is a modification that is not in the recipe! You can also use indirect heat if preferred.

Monitoring Temperature and the Final Rest

Whether I choose the pan and oven method or the grill, I always use a food thermometer to check the internal temperature of my Cowboy Steak. Remember that the beef will gain an additional 3 to 4 degrees after cooking is terminated. Once I take it off the heat, I place it on a cutting board and let it rest for 1 to 2 minutes. I sprinkle it with a final pinch of salt and pepper, then top it with herb butter before serving!

Popular questions

Why do I need to let my Cowboy Steak rest before cooking?

As a chef, I always tell my friends to let the beef rest in its oil and salt marinade for 30 to 60 minutes to prevent a rubbery texture. Leaving the fat intact and letting the meat sit at room temperature helps immensely, whether you use a grill or a hot pan to sear it. Starting with meat that is not freezing cold ensures it cooks evenly before you finish it in the oven!

Cowboy Steak

4 servingsPublished: 4.6.2026 ★★★★★1x(read the reviews)👁486x
15 min.
45 min.
1/5
🖨Print

Ingredients:

Click any ingredient to learn more
Ingredients
1 PCS of cowboy ribeye steak (beef) (preferably 1,5 to 2" thick, about 1 ½ - 2 ½ LB *)
Drizzle of Extra Virgin Olive Oil (adjust if needed)
4 cloves of garlic
Pinch of salt (Generous )
Pinch of pepper - ideally freshly ground
For searing with finishing in the oven only:
2 TBSP of frying oil (any kind) (adjust if needed)
2 fresh rosemary sprigs - fresh and whole
½ stick of unsalted butter (2 oz, sliced to about 8 thick slices)
Final touch:
Pinch of salt
Pinch of pepper - ideally freshly ground
3 servings of herb butter (store-bought or recipe here, 1 TBSP each)

Nutrition per 1 Serving:(recipe split into 4 servings)

Estimated
Calories 704 Protein 1.0 g Fat 79.1 g Saturated fat 46.2 g Carbohydrate 1.1 g Sugars 0.1 g Fiber 0.1 g Sodium 484 mg Cholesterol 192 mg
Gluten-freeLow-carb
Estimated. Worked out from the ingredients above using the United States Department of Agriculture’s FoodData Central reference data. An estimate, not a measurement — brands, sizes and how much of a marinade actually ends up on the plate all move it.
Directions:

1.Meat Preparation:

1.1.
Make sure that the meat is properly rinsed under cold water.

Important:

  • Do not trim the fat from the meat (for this kind of steak, fat is important),
  • Do not pound it
  • and do not cut it into individual steaks.
Cowboy Steak-04
Cowboy Steak-03
Cowboy Steak-02
Cowboy Steak-01
1.2.

Pour and sprinkle these ingredients on both sides of the steak:

1.3.

Briefly massage all ingredients into each meat.

1.4.
Cover the meat with plastic wrap and let rest (marinating) at room temperature for at least 30 minutes, but no more than 1 hour.
Note:
This step is also really important to prevent getting a rubbery texture of meat.

2.Pan Sear with Finishing in the Oven or Grill:

2.1.

Pan sear with finishing in the oven:

2.1.1.

Set oven to preheat at 350°F.

2.1.2.

Preheat the frying pan over medium-high heat with 2 tablespoons of frying oil and add 2 rosemary sprigs to the side.

2.1.3.

Place the steaks in the pan and briefly sear them to achieve a nice sear (about 1-2 minutes per side, including the shorter sides).

2.1.4.

Place the pan off the burner.

2.1.5.

Pour the liquid from the marinade over the steak.

2.1.6.

Add on 8 slices of butter.

2.1.7.

Finish in a preheated oven until the meat reaches the desired internal temperature. *

2.1.8.
In the middle of the baking, turn the meat and pour the juices from the pan over.

Note: Optionally, you can pour the juice over the steaks a couple more times during cooking.

Important: Remember that the meat will gain an additional 3-4°F after cooking is terminated.

2.2.

Grill:

2.2.1.

Preheat grill at 350°F.

2.2.2.
Grill from both sides evenly (preferably with a closed lid) until a nice sear is reached and the meat reaches the desired internal temperature. *
Important:
  • Remember that the meat will gain an additional 3-4°F after cooking is terminated.
  • Watch your grill while grilling.
  • If the meat starts to burn, lower the heat.
  • Optionally, you can grill only with indirect heat.
  • The fire is not directly under the meat but on the side (a closed lid is required for this technique).

3.Rest & Serve:

3.1.

Let the meat rest on a cutting board for about 1 – 2 minutes before serving.

3.2.

Sprinkle with salt and pepper.

3.3.

Place on 3 – 4 servings of her butter.

3.4.

Serve with your favorite side.

* Check with a food thermometer to make sure that you have reached the minimum recommended safe serving temperature for beef, lamb, venison of 145°F.
Kitchen Guide

Beef, Lamb, Venison (steaks, chops, roast)

The USDA minimum safe internal temperature is 145°F.

Popular serving temperatures:

  • 110 – 120°F – Blue
  • 120 – 130°F – Rare
  • 130 – 135°F – Medium Rare (most popular, especially by chefs)
  • 135 – 145°F – Medium
  • 145 – 155°F – Medium Well
  • 155°F and more – Well Done
Read More
Beef, Lamb, Venison (steaks, chops, roast)
Bone-in Cowboy Steak with three pats of herb butter melting on a wooden board
Bone-in Cowboy Steak with three pats of herb butter melting on a wooden boardSeared bone-in Cowboy Steak topped with three dollops of green herb butter on a wooden board.Sliced Cowboy Steak with bone-in roast, seared crust, and herb butter on a wooden boardSeared bone-in Cowboy Steak topped with three dollops of herb butter on a wooden board.Sliced Cowboy Steak with charred crust and herb butter medallions on a wooden cutting boardSeared bone-in Cowboy Steak topped with herb butter, resting on a live-edge wooden board with knife and forkSliced Cowboy Steak with charred crust and herb butter melting on top, on a wooden board.Bone-in Cowboy Steak with charred crust and three herb butter rounds melting on top, on a wooden boardBone-in Cowboy Steak with a dark seared crust, topped with three melting rounds of herb butter, on a wooden board.Bone-in Cowboy Steak with charred crust and three dollops of herb butter on a wooden board.Sliced Cowboy Steak with dark seared crust and pink center, topped with herb butter on a wooden boardBone-in Cowboy Steak with a charred crust, topped with three melting dollops of herb butter on a wooden board.Bone-in Cowboy Steak topped with herb butter, partly sliced to show a pink center, on a wooden board

Cook to safe temperatures and check for allergens. Nutrition values and results are estimates and may vary.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Some of the ingredient and tool links above are affiliate links: if you buy through them the price is the same for you, and it helps keep these recipes free. #ad

Show moreShow less of the Disclaimer

Disclaimer

Last updated October 27, 2026

GENERAL INFORMATION

The content provided by Checked Solutions, LLC (doing business as Tom the Chef) ("we," "us," or "our") on https://www.tomthechef.com (the "Site") and through our related services — including recipes, articles, columns, live and recorded cooking classes, and other materials — is for general informational and educational purposes only and reflects the personal opinions and experience of the author. All information is provided in good faith; however, we make no representation or warranty of any kind, express or implied, regarding the accuracy, adequacy, validity, reliability, availability, or completeness of any information. Your use of the Site and your reliance on any information is solely at your own risk.

NO PROFESSIONAL ADVICE

Our content is not intended to provide, and does not constitute, professional dietary, medical, nutritional, or legal advice. Before making any health- or diet-related decision based on our content, consult a qualified medical or nutritional professional.

COOKING, FOOD SAFETY, AND YOUR RESPONSIBILITY

You are solely responsible for evaluating our recipes and instructions and using your own judgment before following them. To the fullest extent permitted by law, we are not responsible for any outcome or consequence resulting from your use of the Site or our content, including but not limited to:

  • Food Safety: any health risk related to food handling, food quality, cross-contamination, or failure to follow USDA recommendations (including minimum safe cooking temperatures).
  • Preparation Safety: the safe handling of cooking equipment, hot surfaces, sharp knives, or the suitability of tools for any task.
  • Allergies and Dietary Restrictions: any allergic reaction or health issue arising from ingredients in our recipes. You are responsible for ensuring that all ingredients and methods are safe and appropriate for your dietary restrictions, allergies, and health.
  • Recipe Outcomes: the final look, taste, yield, or success of a recipe, which may vary based on ingredients, equipment, oven temperatures, altitude, humidity, and skill.
  • Ingredients and Equipment: the sourcing, quality, and condition of ingredients, tools, or equipment.
  • Nutritional Information: the accuracy of any nutritional data, which is an estimate provided as a courtesy and should not be relied on as a guarantee.
  • Errors and Omissions: any errors, typos, or unclear directions in our content.

EXTERNAL LINKS

The Site may contain links to third-party websites or content, including in banners or other advertising. We do not investigate, monitor, or guarantee the accuracy or reliability of third-party sites. We are not responsible for them or for any transaction between you and a third party. Accessing third-party sites is at your own risk.

TESTIMONIALS, REVIEWS, AND COMMENTS

The Site may contain testimonials, reviews, and comments from users. These reflect the personal experiences and opinions of individual users and may not be representative of all users; your individual results may vary. Testimonials and reviews may be shortened for brevity or corrected for grammar. The views expressed belong solely to the individual. They are not intended as claims that our products or services diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease or medical condition.

CONTENT OWNERSHIP

All content published by Tom the Chef is the intellectual property of Checked Solutions, LLC and its author, unless otherwise noted, and may not be used except as permitted in our Terms of Use.

AFFILIATE DISCLOSURE

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Some ingredient and tool links on the Site are affiliate links. If you buy through them, the price is the same for you, and it helps support our content. We only recommend products we genuinely use and trust.

LIMITATION OF LIABILITY

Under no circumstances shall Checked Solutions, LLC or Tom the Chef have any liability to you for any loss or damage of any kind incurred as a result of the use of the Site or reliance on any information provided. This Disclaimer forms part of, and is subject to, our Terms of Use.