What is the main difference between the pan-searing and grilling methods for this Pesto Chicken Sandwich with Parmesan?

The main difference between the two cooking methods I've included in my Pesto Chicken Sandwich with Parmesan recipe lies in the final flavor and texture of the chicken breast. The pan-sear and oven-finish method is all about creating a uniform, golden-brown crust on the chicken. This is achieved by searing it in a hot pan with oil, which gives the surface a rich, savory flavor. Finishing it in the oven ensures it cooks through gently, keeping the inside very juicy. This method is great for indoor cooking and consistency. On the other hand, the grilling method imparts a distinct smoky flavor and classic char marks that you can only get from a grill. This option is perfect for outdoor cooking and gives the homemade sandwich a summery, barbecue feel. Both methods produce a delicious and perfectly cooked pan-seared chicken or grilled chicken, so the choice really comes down to whether you prefer the savory crust of a pan-sear or the smoky notes of the grill for your easy recipe.

Recipes

Pesto Chicken Sandwich with Parmesan

Tired of the same old lunch routine? I created this sensational Pesto Chicken Sandwich with Parmesan to elevate your sandwich game. This recipe transforms a simple chicken breast into a masterpiece of flavor, featuring juicy, tender chicken marinated in zesty lemon and garlic, then slathered with vibrant basil pesto and crowned with a layer of melted, nutty Parmesan cheese. Perfect for a satisfying weeknight dinner, a standout lunch, or the star of your next backyard barbecue, this sandwich is as versatile as it is delicious. Assembled on a toasted bun with creamy garlic aioli and fresh toppings, this is a restaurant-quality meal you can easily create in your own kitchen.

Tom the Chef Founder

Published:
September 25, 2025

Before You Start

Let’s talk about important parts of the recipe before you start…

Introduction

I’m so excited to share my recipe for the ultimate Pesto Chicken Sandwich with Parmesan with you! If you’re looking for a chicken breast recipe that is packed with flavor and results in incredibly juicy chicken, you’ve come to the right place. This isn’t just any sandwich; it’s a complete meal that feels gourmet but is surprisingly simple to make. We’ll take a boneless, skinless chicken breast and marinate it with lemon, garlic, and beautiful basil pesto. Then, you have the choice to either pan-sear it and finish it in the oven or cook it on the grill for a smoky flavor. We finish it with a generous layer of Parmesan cheese and serve this Parmesan Chicken on a toasted bun with a creamy garlic aioli. It’s the perfect homemade sandwich for an easy weeknight dinner or a special weekend lunch.

The Science of Marinating for Flavor

The marinade is where the magic really begins for this Pesto Chicken Sandwich with Parmesan. It’s a simple yet powerful combination of lemon juice, extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic, basil pesto, salt, and pepper. The lemon juice not only adds a bright, zesty flavor but also helps to tenderize the chicken breast. The garlic and basil pesto infuse the meat with deep, aromatic, and herbaceous notes. Salt is especially important, as I noted in the recipe, because it does more than just season; it helps the chicken retain moisture and enhances all the other flavors. I recommend letting the chicken marinate at room temperature for about 15 minutes. This short time is enough for the flavors to begin penetrating the surface of the meat. If you have more time, you can marinate it overnight in the refrigerator for a much deeper flavor infusion, but I suggest letting it sit at room temperature for the last 30 minutes before cooking to ensure it cooks evenly.

Mastering the Two-Step Cooking Method: Pan-Sear and Oven Finish

For a perfect pan-seared chicken, I use a two-step method that guarantees a delicious result. This technique is fantastic for my Pesto Chicken Sandwich with Parmesan because it creates a beautiful crust while keeping the inside incredibly moist. I start by preheating a fry pan on medium-high heat with a bit of oil. Searing the chicken for about two minutes on one side creates a gorgeous, golden-brown crust through the Maillard reaction, which develops immense flavor. After flipping the chicken, I add the final layer of basil pesto and a generous sprinkle of Parmesan cheese. Then, the entire pan goes into a preheated 350°F oven for just 3-4 minutes to finish cooking. This second step allows the chicken to cook through gently without burning the exterior, while also perfectly melting the cheese on top. It’s the best way to get a juicy, flavorful, and perfectly cooked chicken breast every time.

Choosing Your Cooking Adventure: Grill vs. Pan

My Pesto Chicken Sandwich with Parmesan recipe offers you two fantastic cooking options: pan-searing with an oven finish or grilling. Your choice depends on the flavor profile you prefer. The pan-sear method, as I described, gives you a consistent, savory crust that’s rich and delicious. Grilling, on the other hand, imparts a classic smoky flavor and those beautiful char marks that many of us love, especially for a backyard barbecue. When grilling, I preheat the grill to 350°F and cook the chicken for about 2 minutes per side, adding the basil pesto and Parmesan cheese after the first flip. I suggest keeping the grill lid closed as much as possible to create an oven-like environment, which helps the chicken cook evenly and melts the cheese beautifully. Both methods yield a fantastic grilled chicken or pan-seared chicken, so you can’t go wrong with either for your homemade sandwich.

The Crucial Role of Pesto and Cheese

The basil pesto and Parmesan cheese are the true stars of this Pesto Chicken Sandwich with Parmesan. I intentionally use pesto in two different stages of the recipe to maximize its impact. First, a small amount goes into the marinade, where its herby, garlicky flavor seeps into the chicken breast itself. Then, a more generous layer is spread on top of the chicken during cooking. This second application provides a fresh, vibrant burst of basil flavor that perfectly complements the cooked chicken. As for the cheese, Parmesan is my top choice for its nutty, salty flavor that crisps up beautifully when cooked. However, I also include an option to add shredded Mozzarella. The Mozzarella doesn’t add as much flavor, but it provides that satisfying, stringy cheese-pull that can make a sandwich feel extra indulgent. The combination of basil pesto and Parmesan cheese is a classic pairing that truly defines this recipe.

Why You Shouldn’t Skip Toasting the Buns

A small detail that makes a huge difference in any homemade sandwich is toasting the buns, and my Pesto Chicken Sandwich with Parmesan is no exception. While this step is optional, I highly recommend it. Toasting the cut sides of the burger buns or ciabatta creates a delicate, crispy texture that provides a wonderful contrast to the soft, juicy chicken and creamy garlic aioli. More importantly, the toasted surface acts as a barrier, preventing the bun from becoming soggy from the sauces and toppings. You can easily toast them in a toaster, or for extra flavor, spread a thin layer of butter on them and sear them for a moment on a hot pan or the grill. This simple step elevates the entire sandwich experience, ensuring every bite is as good as the first.

Ensuring Perfection and Safety: The Food Thermometer

When it comes to cooking poultry, safety and taste go hand-in-hand. That’s why I can’t stress enough the importance of using a food thermometer for this Pesto Chicken Sandwich with Parmesan. The only way to be absolutely certain that your chicken breast is cooked through safely is to check its internal temperature. According to USDA guidelines, poultry should reach a minimum internal temperature of 165°F to be safe to eat. Guessing based on time or color can be unreliable and can lead to either undercooked, unsafe chicken or overcooked, dry chicken. A food thermometer removes all the guesswork. Simply insert it into the thickest part of the chicken breast to get an accurate reading. This ensures your pan-seared chicken or grilled chicken is not only safe but also perfectly juicy and tender, which is exactly what you want for this easy recipe.

Building the Perfect Pesto Chicken Sandwich with Parmesan

The final assembly is where all the delicious components of the Pesto Chicken Sandwich with Parmesan come together. Once your buns are toasted and your chicken is perfectly cooked, it’s time to build your masterpiece. I like to start by spreading a generous amount of garlic aioli on both halves of the bun. This creamy, garlicky sauce is the perfect base. On the bottom bun, I place a couple of leaves of crisp lettuce, which adds a fresh crunch. The star of the show, the warm pesto and Parmesan-topped chicken breast, goes right on top of the lettuce. Next, I add a couple of slices of fresh tomato for a touch of juicy acidity. For an extra layer of flavor, I sometimes add finely chopped sun-dried tomatoes to the top bun along with the aioli. Finally, I place the top bun on, and the sandwich is ready to be served. Each layer is designed to complement the others, creating a balanced and incredibly flavorful homemade sandwich perfect for any weeknight dinner.

Recipe

(click on any ingredients and tool to learn more on CookingHub.com)